Crop't Fresh logoRequest Product

Questions to Ask a Produce Broker Before You Sign

9 questions to ask a produce broker before you sign: who buys your crop, whose name is on the box, fees and deductions, when you get paid, plus how to read a settlement sheet, red flags and what PACA protects.

Questions to Ask a Produce Broker Before You Sign

Short answer: Before you sign with a produce broker, ask which buyers it sells to now, whose name goes on the box, and whether it will show you what the buyer paid. Ask for its commission, every possible deduction and its payment terms in writing. Then check its PACA license and its Blue Book or Red Book rating, and talk to growers it sells for now. A good broker answers all of these without hesitating. Crop't Fresh is a PACA-licensed produce sales company in St. Petersburg, Florida (PACA #20251139, Blue Book #421379). It sells family farms' crops to retail buyers under the farm's own label.

9 questions to ask before you sign

  1. Which buyers do you sell to now, and for how long? Ask for the stores and distributors by name.
  2. Whose name goes on the box? Some brokers sell under their own label. If building your farm's name matters to you, get your label in the agreement.
  3. Will you tell me who bought my crop and what they paid? You should be able to see it.
  4. What's your commission or fee, and what can be deducted? Get a written list: freight, cooling, palletizing, inspection, rejections.
  5. When will I be paid? Under PACA, the default is payment within 10 days after the buyer accepts the produce. Longer terms must be agreed in writing before the sale, and terms over 30 days lose PACA trust protection.
  6. How do you handle a rejection or a price adjustment? Ask whether they'll get a USDA inspection before they accept a buyer's claim.
  7. Who handles the paperwork? That means vendor setup, food safety audits, case labels and traceability records.
  8. Is the agreement exclusive, and how do I end it? Read the notice period and any limits on selling to the same buyers yourself.
  9. Can I talk to two or three growers you sell for now?

Still deciding whether you need a broker at all? Start with how to choose a produce broker when your family farm is ready to scale.

What a produce broker does, and when it makes sense

A broker sells your crop to buyers it already knows: grocery chains, distributors, foodservice companies and wholesalers. It finds the buyer, negotiates the sale and often arranges the freight, so you can stay in the field.

A broker is a good fit when:

  • You don't have time or staff to sell, and you'd rather grow.
  • You don't know the buyers at the chains or distributors you want to reach.
  • Your season is short and you need to be part of a bigger program that covers the buyer's whole season.
  • You want help moving the whole crop, including the product that doesn't make retail grade.

You're not alone if finding buyers is the hard part. In ProducePay's 2022 national survey of U.S. produce growers and buyers, 50% of growers said they have difficulty finding consistent buyers. 68% said reaching fair pricing terms was their biggest pain point in trading. Those are the two jobs a good broker should take off your plate.

And stores are looking for farms. In FMI's State of Fresh Foods 2026 report, 87% of food retailers said they used local produce to set themselves apart in 2025. In The Packer's Fresh Trends 2025 survey, two in three shoppers said they feel strongly about buying locally grown produce.

Broker, commission merchant or dealer: know which one you're signing with

Under the federal Perishable Agricultural Commodities Act (PACA), the companies that sell produce for growers come in three kinds. Which kind you sign with changes who owns your produce and what records you get.

TypeWhat it doesWho owns the produce?
BrokerNegotiates the sale between you and the buyer for a fee or commissionYou, until the buyer takes it
Commission merchant / grower's agentTakes your produce and sells it on your behalf, then pays you what it sold for minus its commission and costsYou, until it's sold
DealerBuys your produce outright and resells itThe dealer, from the moment it buys

Many companies do more than one of these. Ask which role they're playing for your crop, and get it in writing.

Broker vs distributor vs marketplace: A distributor buys your crop and resells it to its own customers under its terms. A marketplace or app lists your crop for buyers to find, and you do the follow-up. A broker or sales company works the buyer relationships for you. A farm with steady volume and no sales staff usually gets the most out of a broker or sales company.

How produce brokers are paid

Brokers usually charge a percentage commission on the sale or a set fee per package. Some charge both, plus costs like cooling, palletizing or freight that they pay up front and take back out of your settlement. There's no single "right" percentage. It depends on the crop, the volume and how much work the broker does for you. What matters most is that you know the rate, and every possible deduction, before the first load ships.

Is it worth paying a broker just for its buyer connections? It can be. Building relationships with chain category managers takes years. If a broker's connections get your crop into a program you couldn't reach on your own, the commission can pay for itself. Ask the broker to name the buyers it sells to now.

What's a fair price? Don't compare your return with the shelf price. Most of what a shopper pays covers packing, freight, the store and everyone in between. USDA's Economic Research Service found that since 2010, growers received 20% to 29% of the grocery store price for a basket of 16 fresh vegetables, and 32% to 39% for a basket of 13 fresh fruits. The better test is whether your broker shows you what the buyer paid and every deduction between that and your check.

How to read a settlement sheet

A settlement sheet, also called an account of sale, should show for each load:

  • The buyer and the date the buyer received it
  • How much was sold, and at what price
  • Each deduction listed by itself: commission, freight, cooling, inspection, adjustments
  • The net amount paid to you

Is it normal for a settlement to come weeks later with deductions you don't understand? Some lag is normal while the buyer pays. Deductions you can't explain are not. Ask for the buyer's invoice or proof of sale, and for the USDA inspection certificate behind any rejection or price adjustment. A broker you can trust will send them without arguing.

Red flags

  • It won't tell you who bought your crop or what they paid.
  • Its commission and deductions aren't in writing.
  • It has no PACA license, or a low or missing Blue Book or Red Book rating.
  • Settlement sheets show lump-sum "adjustments" with no inspection behind them.
  • Payment keeps slipping past the agreed terms.
  • Other growers won't vouch for it.

You can look up a company's PACA license with USDA's PACA program. Blue Book Services and Red Book Credit Services rate produce companies on payment and integrity.

If your broker pays late

  1. Check your agreement for the payment terms you agreed to.
  2. If you're unlicensed (most growers are), send the buyer a written notice that you're keeping your PACA trust rights. Send it within 30 days after payment was due.
  3. Ask in writing for payment and for the account of sale.
  4. If you're still not paid, contact USDA's PACA program. It handles complaints from unpaid produce sellers.

How Crop't Fresh works with family farms

Crop't Fresh is a produce sales company founded by Christina Monnin, named to Produce Business magazine's 40 Under Forty in 2025. She has spent more than 19 years selling for grower-shippers including Duda Farm Fresh Foods, Van Solkema Family Farms and Cottle Strawberry Nursery. Connect with her on LinkedIn. Here's how we answer the questions above:

  • Buyers we work with: Our team has relationships with fresh produce buyers at grocery chains including Publix, Walmart, Kroger, H-E-B, Meijer, Food Lion, Sprouts, Trader Joe's, The Fresh Market, Target, Save A Lot and Loblaw in Canada, and at distributors and foodservice companies including Sysco, US Foods, Gordon Food Service, UNFI, FreshPoint and Baldor.
  • Your name on the box: We sell under your farm's label.
  • Buy outright or sell on commission: We can buy your crop and resell it, or sell it for you on commission. We set it up the way each grower wants.
  • Terms in writing: We set terms with each farm based on its crop, volume and season, and put them in writing before the first load ships.
  • Paperwork: We help with vendor setup, audit readiness and traceability.
  • The whole crop: Retail-grade product goes to retail. What doesn't make grade goes to wholesale, processors or frozen.
  • Licensed and listed: PACA license #20251139, Blue Book Services BB #421379, and a certified woman-owned small business.

Would you rather keep the buyer accounts in your own farm's name? Some farms want to bill the stores themselves and keep the customer. Our sister company Grow Desk is a sales team that opens accounts in your farm's name and does the selling for you. It never buys or sells your produce.

Common questions

What questions should I ask a produce broker before signing?
Ask which buyers it sells to now, whose name goes on the box, whether it will show you the buyer's price, what its commission and deductions are, when you'll be paid, how it handles rejections, who does the paperwork, how the agreement ends, and which growers you can call.

How do I choose a produce broker for my family farm?
Pick one that already sells to the buyers you want and holds a PACA license with a good Blue Book or Red Book rating. It should put its commission, deductions and payment terms in writing, and other growers should vouch for it.

Is it normal for a broker not to tell me who's buying my crop?
Some brokers don't share it. You can still ask, and a broker that keeps your name on the box and shows you the buyer's price is easier to trust.

How much do produce brokers charge?
Usually a percentage commission on the sale or a fee per package, plus certain costs. Rates depend on the crop, volume and services. Get the rate and every possible deduction in writing before you ship.

What makes a broker "direct" rather than a middleman?
A direct broker sells your crop straight to the retailer or distributor that uses it, under your name, and shows you that buyer and price. A middleman passes your crop through other traders before it reaches the store.

Is there a produce broker on the East Coast that works with small family farms?
Yes. Crop't Fresh is based in St. Petersburg, Florida, and works with family farms along the East Coast and beyond, pairing farms across regions so buyers get a full season.

Sources

Keep reading

Looking for a broker for this season? Tell us what you grow. We'll tell you which buyers it fits.

Our sister company

Want to keep your buyer accounts in your own name? Grow Desk works as your in-house sales team.

Visit Grow Desk